Why You’re Calm One Day and Anxious the Next

Why You’re Calm One Day and Anxious the Next

The Nervous System Imbalance Nobody Explains

Have you ever noticed this?

One day, everything feels manageable.
Your supplements work. Your focus is steady. Your body feels calm.

Then—seemingly out of nowhere—the next day you’re anxious, wired, overstimulated, or on edge.

Same routine.
Same sleep.
Same supplements.

So what changed?

The answer most people never hear is this:

Your nervous system state changed.

Not your personality.
Not your discipline.
Not your mindset.

Your biology.


Anxiety Isn’t Random — It’s State-Dependent

We’re taught to think of anxiety as a fixed trait:

“I’m an anxious person.”

But in reality, anxiety is often state-dependent, meaning it fluctuates based on how regulated your nervous system is in that moment.

Your nervous system constantly shifts between two primary modes:

  • Sympathetic (fight or flight)

  • Parasympathetic (rest, digest, repair)

Think of it like a car:

  • Sympathetic = gas pedal

  • Parasympathetic = brake

You need both.

The problem isn’t having a gas pedal.
The problem is living with it pressed down all the time.


Modern Life Keeps the Gas Pedal Stuck

A cartoon of a foot on a floored gas pedal

Even if your life looks “normal,” your nervous system may be under constant load from things like:

  • Chronic stress

  • Poor light exposure

  • Inconsistent sleep

  • Blood sugar swings

  • Overstimulation (screens, caffeine, noise)

  • Nutrient depletion

  • Inflammatory or gut stress

Over time, the nervous system adapts by staying hyper-alert.

That adaptation can look like:

  • Racing thoughts

  • Sensory sensitivity

  • Tight chest or jaw

  • Palpitations

  • Feeling “tired but wired”

  • Calm one day, anxious the next

This isn’t weakness.

It’s your nervous system doing its job — just too often.


The Glutamate–GABA Balance Most People Miss

a balanced brain - calm

At the neurochemical level, much of this comes down to balance between two key neurotransmitters:

  • Glutamate → excitatory (go, focus, alertness)

  • GABA → inhibitory (calm, stability, braking)

Both are essential.

Glutamate helps you think, learn, and respond.
GABA helps you feel safe enough to slow down.

Problems arise when:

  • Glutamate signaling stays high

  • GABA tone can’t keep up

That imbalance can feel like anxiety — even if nothing is “wrong” psychologically.


Why Supplements Can Help One Day… and Backfire the Next

This is where many people get confused and frustrated.

You take something that:

  • Helps focus

  • Improves mood

  • Reduces fatigue

And then suddenly:

  • It causes anxiety

  • You feel overstimulated

  • Your heart races

  • Your sleep worsens

Common examples include:

  • Methylated B vitamins

  • Adaptogens

  • Choline or acetylcholine boosters

  • Certain nootropics

  • Even calming supplements taken at the wrong time

This doesn’t mean the supplement is “bad.”

It often means your nervous system state wasn’t ready for stimulation that day.

When baseline stress is already high, even supportive inputs can push the system further into fight-or-flight.


Calm Is Not the Same as Sedation

One of the biggest misunderstandings in the wellness space is confusing calm with sedation.

True calm looks like:

  • Stable energy

  • Clear thinking

  • Emotional resilience

  • Faster recovery from stress

Not:

  • Numbness

  • Brain fog

  • Feeling flat or dull

The goal isn’t to suppress the nervous system.

The goal is to support balance so it can regulate itself.


Nervous System Resilience Is the Real Target

Instead of asking:

“What can I take to calm me down?”

A better question is:

“What helps my nervous system handle stress more effectively?”

Resilience means:

  • Less reactivity

  • Faster return to baseline

  • More consistent days

  • Fewer crashes after stimulation

This is built gradually, not forced.


Foundations That Actually Support Regulation

beautiful sunrise

(No products. No hype.)

Here are evidence-backed principles that support nervous system balance:

1. Minerals Before Stimulants
Magnesium and other minerals help stabilize nerve signaling. Deficiency makes everything feel louder.

2. Amino Acid Balance
Neurotransmitters are built from amino acids. Balance matters more than boosting one pathway.

3. Light Exposure
Morning sunlight anchors circadian rhythm and cortisol patterns.

4. Breathing Patterns
Slow, nasal breathing sends a “safe” signal to the nervous system.

5. Consistency Over Intensity
Small, repeated signals of safety outperform aggressive interventions.

These aren’t quick fixes — they’re regulators.


The Nine Lives Perspective

At Nine Lives, we don’t believe your nervous system is broken.

We believe it’s adaptive — shaped by environment, stress, and inputs over time.

Calm isn’t something you force.
It’s something you support at the cellular level.

When the system feels safe, clarity returns.
Energy stabilizes.
And anxiety loses its grip — not through suppression, but through balance.


If this resonated, you’re not alone.

This conversation is just beginning.
And understanding your nervous system is one of the most powerful steps toward lasting resilience.


Nine Lives Longevity

Back to blog

1 comment

There are some things listed I can associate with.
Issues with my sleep have always been a problem
and my stress levels, especially during the period of time I was unemployed. The information I have read so far is very interesting and I look forward to learning more.

Louise McGarrett

Leave a comment